ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom. Signal up for The Big Tale e-newsletter to obtain stories like this a single in your inbox.
On a summertime working day past yr, a group of true estate tech executives gathered at a convention hall in Nashville to boast about a single of their company’s signature products: program that uses a mysterious algorithm to help landlords drive the best probable rents on tenants.
“Never just before have we observed these quantities,” said Jay Parsons, a vice president of RealPage, as conventiongoers wandered by. Condominium rents had lately shot up by as substantially as 14.5 per cent, he explained in a online video touting the company’s providers. Turning to his colleague, Parsons asked: What purpose had the program played?
“I consider it is driving it, rather honestly,” answered Andrew Bowen, yet another RealPage government. “As a property supervisor, really handful of of us would be ready to basically increase rents double digits in just a solitary month by executing it manually.”
The celebratory remarks have been extra than swagger. For many years, RealPage has offered computer software that works by using facts analytics to advise each day costs for open up models. House supervisors across the United States have gushed about how the company’s algorithm boosts revenue.
“The attractiveness of YieldStar is that it pushes you to go destinations that you wouldn’t have long gone if you weren’t working with it,” explained Kortney Balas, director of earnings administration at JVM Realty, referring to RealPage’s application in a testimonial movie on the company’s internet site.
The nation’s greatest house management agency, Greystar, discovered that even in just one downturn, its properties working with YieldStar “outperformed their marketplaces by 4.8 p.c,” a substantial top quality above opponents, RealPage stated in supplies on its site. Greystar makes use of RealPage’s program to selling price tens of 1000’s of residences.
RealPage turned the nation’s dominant supplier of these lease-setting software program soon after federal regulators permitted a controversial merger in 2017, a ProPublica investigation uncovered, greatly increasing the company’s influence about condominium charges. The transfer served the Texas-primarily based firm push the shopper foundation for its array of genuine estate tech expert services past 31,700 prospects.
The effects is stark in some markets.
In one neighborhood in Seattle, ProPublica discovered, 70 p.c of apartments have been overseen by just 10 home supervisors, each and every single one particular of which made use of pricing software offered by RealPage.
To get there at a advised lease, the software deploys an algorithm—a set of mathematical rules—to assess a trove of data RealPage gathers from consumers, including private information and facts on what nearby competition charge.
For tenants, the program upends the exercise of negotiating with apartment constructing team. RealPage discourages bargaining with renters and has even suggested that landlords in some scenarios settle for a reduce occupancy amount in get to increase rents and make much more dollars.
1 of the algorithm’s builders instructed ProPublica that leasing brokers had “too a lot empathy” when compared to laptop or computer-produced pricing.
Apartment supervisors can reject the software’s suggestions, but as numerous as 90 percent are adopted, in accordance to previous RealPage staff members.
The software’s style and design and developing attain have lifted queries between true estate and legal professionals about whether RealPage has birthed a new variety of cartel that allows the nation’s biggest landlords to indirectly coordinate pricing, most likely in violation of federal law.
Professionals say RealPage and its clients invite scrutiny from antitrust enforcers for quite a few factors, including their use of non-public information on what competition demand in rent. In specific, RealPage’s development of function groups that meet up with privately and incorporate landlords who are if not rivals could be a pink flag of likely collusion, a previous federal prosecutor stated.
At a bare minimum, critics said, the software’s algorithm might be artificially inflating rents and stifling competitors.
“Machines rapidly discover the only way to get is to press prices earlier mentioned competitive concentrations,” claimed University of Tennessee legislation professor Maurice Stucke, a former prosecutor in the Justice Department’s antitrust division.
RealPage acknowledged that it feeds its clients’ inside lease data into its pricing application, supplying landlords an aggregated, anonymous glance at what their rivals close by are charging.
A enterprise agent said in an electronic mail that RealPage “uses aggregated market place information from a wide variety of sources in a lawfully compliant method.”
The business pointed out that landlords who use staff members to manually set prices “typically” carry out cell phone surveys to look at competitors’ rents, which the company says could end result in anti-competitive conduct.
“RealPage’s earnings management methods prioritize a property’s have inside offer/need dynamics about exterior components these as competitors’ rents,” a company assertion explained, “and as a result aid do away with the chance of collusion that could occur with manual pricing.”
The assertion mentioned RealPage’s application also allows protect against rents from achieving unaffordable amounts for the reason that it detects drops in demand, like those that materialize seasonally, and can respond to them by decreasing rents.
RealPage did not make Parsons, Bowen, or the company’s existing CEO, Dana Jones, obtainable for interviews. Balas and a Greystar agent declined to remark on the record about YieldStar. The National Multifamily Housing Council, an sector group, also declined to remark.
Proponents say the computer software is not distorting the market place. RealPage’s CEO advised traders five decades in the past that the firm would not be massive more than enough to hurt competitiveness even right after the merger. The CEO of just one of YieldStar’s earliest customers, Ric Campo of Camden Property Have confidence in, instructed ProPublica that the apartment current market in his company’s home town alone is so major and assorted that “it would be difficult to argue there was some kind of cost fixing.”